Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Felon Mark Allen Mathis of Mr. C's Towing Manager Convicted of Stealing Cars in 2005, Over 21 Years of Alleged Thieving (Guest Post by Marilyn Angel)

Mark Mathis, the general manager of Mr. C’s Towing ("Mr. C's") has a secret he doesn’t want you to know about. In July 2005, Mark A. Mathis (“Mathis”) was arrested on charges of conspiracy and unlawful taking of vehicles in the City of Huntington Beach. Shortly after, prosecutors filed a felony case against him and was disposed in November of 2005.

According to the LA Times, police said Mathis, then a night supervisor at Medlin’s Towing, drove around private parking lots with Sean Hyepock looking for illegally parked cars. Hyepock would pretend to be a property manager to approve the tows. Police said five cars were towed without the property owners’ permission and that the men were after towing and storage fees. The case number in that case is 05WF1906.

A private investigative firm hired by The Legal Lens found that Mathis may also have 2 more charges. One is a misdemeanor citation from 2005; the other is a complaint from 1999. ((WE740205, 2005); 1 complaint (C-98352, 1999) respectively). The investigator also found a $2,078 judgment recorded in 2009 with the same felony case number listed, 05WF1906.

That kind of judgment usually reflects unpaid court fines, fees, or money owed to a victim, usually following a conviction. Upon a CPRA request for these records, the Orange County DA’s Office informed the Legal Lens that Mathis’s records had been expunged, so the information could only be shared with him or a qualifying criminal justice agency. In other words, it appears Mathis stiffed his victims for years, even after being convicted.

According to the Press-Telegram, three years after Mathis’s arrest, Mr. C’s Towing was accused of illegal towing in the City of Long Beach. In June 2008, police went undercover after receiving several complaints of illegal towing at a shopping center.


Within 20 minutes, a Mr. C’s truck towed an undercover officer’s car. Police arrested two tow truck drivers and a security guard. Sadly, in January 2009, a judge threw out the charges against the other driver and the guard for lack of evidence.


Thankfully, by then, Mr. C’s had lost its Long Beach towing contract. Its manager, Mike Welsh, denied the company had ever towed illegally and said it still had contracts with 11 other cities.


Returning to Mark Allen Mathis, more than 21 years later, nothing has changed except that Mathis seems to improved at taking cars without getting caught. Here's the method he uses: Get city contracts to provide the company credibility and profit. Make many political campaign donations and create ties to local governments to gain access and cover. Expunge old criminal cases to hide any questionable reputations. Lastly, don't operate in white cities but do operate in cities where vulnerable populations such as working-class Mexican families and people with disabilities are often overlooked and can be easily taken advantage of. 


Old habits die hard. The Legal Lens contends that the law prohibits cities and towing companies from having convicted felons handling city tows. However, the better question is, why do cities and police departments want to keep working with them? One has to ask.

No comments:

Post a Comment